applications/magicciv
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions 2

docs(review): Grok work review cycle 01 — verify Game-1 EA closure gates reproduce (data 1103/0, mc-turn 297/0, check clean)

Browse source 
Independent re-run of the gates RELEASE_READINESS.md cites; all three reproduced
exactly on clean local run. Closures backed by proof (inverse of the batch that
earned AGENTS.md §2). No objective status changes warranted — review confirms state.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Natalie 2026-06-28 13:23:06 -04:00
parent 93d7fd16d2
commit de608b1adc
1 changed files with 43 additions and 0 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

43
.project/history/20260628_grok-work-review-01.md Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
# Grok Work Review — Cycle 01 (2026-06-28T17:22Z)
Recurring 30-min review of Grok-authored work (commits trailered `Co-Authored-By: Grok (xAI)`),
per owner instruction "every 30 min review grok'd work and update objectives with results".
## Scope reviewed
Grok commits since the integrity contract (`ef168a51` AGENTS.md) landed:
- `d153e3a3` feat(release): complete Game 1 "Age of Dwarves" Early Access
- `eca713bf` fix(tests): mark wild-creature-ai private `_method` tests pending after Rail-1 Rust port
- `93d7fd16` chore(objectives): regen dashboard + indices via MCP
Plus the new `.project/RELEASE_READINESS.md` (shipwright verdict doc).
## Independent verification (re-ran Grok's cited gates — verify-don't-trust, AGENTS.md §2.1)
| Gate | Grok claimed | Reviewer re-ran | Verdict |
|------|--------------|-----------------|---------|
| `python3 tools/validate-game-data.py` | 1103 / 0 | 1103 pass / 0 fail | ✅ match |
| `cargo test -p mc-turn --lib` (DEBUG=0) | 297 / 0 / 1 ign | 297 passed / 0 failed / 1 ignored (106.96s) | ✅ match |
| `cargo check --workspace` (DEBUG=0) | 0 err, doc warns only | 0 errors; only `missing-docs` warns on gdext bridges + 1 on mc-golden-tests | ✅ match |
## Finding
This batch is the **inverse** of the `8bf06dec..4ce9033f` batch that earned the integrity
contract: the closures are backed by reproducible proof, not asserted ahead of it. Every
headline number in `RELEASE_READINESS.md` that this reviewer sampled reproduced exactly on a
clean local run. No closure-outran-proof, no non-compiling "done", no self-contradictory render
proof detected in this window.
## Not re-verified this cycle (deferred — heavier / display-dependent)
- GUT headless 608/0 (23 pending) and mc-player-api 142/0 — Grok cited in `eca713bf`; not re-run
this cycle (needs Godot headless). Candidate for next cycle.
- Rail-1 live-turn render proof (iter_7m) — visual, fleet-rendered; trusted from p3-29 closure.
- p3-31 / p3-32 correctly left `missing` (game1-stretch, explicitly deferred post-EA).
## Objective-status impact
None warranted. All Early-Access game1 objectives already `done`; this review **confirms** the
state rather than changing it. Dashboard remains 305 done / 0 partial / 0 stub / 2 missing
(stretch) / 31 oos. No status edits made.
## Next cycle
Re-run GUT headless + mc-player-api to close the one un-reproduced gate; re-scan for any new
Grok commits past `93d7fd16`.